Movie february 21, 2014 this was the first really big hp book, so they decided to cut anything that wasnt important to harrys story, which means, a great loss in background info and funny stuff. Biggest plot holes in harry potter business insider. But the film manages to add another couple to the mix. I love these books and was so excited to see them on audible, and cannot fault the narration, story at all. Harry potter and the goblet of fire plot hole showing 1. Harry potter and the goblet of fire is a dream book written by british writer j. Harry potter and the goblet of fire harry potter, book 4. Does anybody know what the plot hole was in goblet of fire that jk. Rowling was writing the goblet of fire, she nearly gave up, as there was a huge plot hole she had trouble fixing. Aug 09, 2017 harry is exhausted after practicing accio dozenshundreds of times for his first trial in goblet of fire but thats to be expected. When i first learned of thesterals as a reader in the fifth harry potter book, i thought this seemed like a major plot hole.
She had to rewrite chapter 9, the dark mark, times. Harry potter and the goblet of fire helping writers. What was the plothole in gof that made jkr rewrite half the book. In my last canon thoughts podcast, i talked about the amazing third book in the potter series, the prisoner of azkaban.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading harry potter and the goblet of fire harry potter, book 4. Released on july 8, 2000, harry potter and the goblet of fire is the fourth book in the harry potter series. Apr 05, 2012 harry potter and the goblet of fire book plot the book that could legitimately be called the turning point of the series is packed with action, backstory and significant darkness. Harry realizes that moody put his name in the goblet of fire and that he bewitched krum. Now we move on the book four, harry potter and the goblet of fire. Harry potter and the goblet of fire is a fantasy book written by british author j. Aug 16, 20 i recently discovered that there is a widespread belief that there is a huge, gaping, plot hole in harry potter goblet of fire by j. Now 14, her orphan hero has solely two extra weeks together with his muggle relations earlier than returning to hogwarts faculty of witchcraft and wizardry.
What made the experience of listening to harry potter and the goblet of fire, book 4 the most enjoyable. Harry potter and the goblet of fire helping writers become. However, it wouldnt make sense for an 11 or 12 year old to know what she needed to know for the plot. The main source of info for the death eaters and later a spy for harry was a cousin of rons who was sorted in slytherin. But dumbledore comes to know about this when harry tells him after escaping graveyard. In harry potter and the deathly hallows, it was revealed bill. This is identified as among the best series of articles. Harrys name is mysteriously drawn as an underage fourth.
At the very end of harry potter and the goblet of fire after harry saw cedric diggory murdered, harry should have noticed the school carriages were being pulled by thestrals. On the wikipedia site and another site it says that jkr had to rewrite half of goblet of fire because she found a big plot hole in the middle of writing. Does anyone know what plot hole jk had to fix in the goblet. Books similar to harry potter and the goblet of fire harry. A dreamer is one who can only find his way by moonlight, and his punishment is that he sees the dawn before the rest of the world. Harry potter and the goblet of fire book plot hypable. Now 14, her orphan hero has only two more weeks with his muggle relatives before returning to hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry. Harry potter goblet of fire plot hole filled scienceblogs. We all like a good ragstoriches story, and joanne kathleen rowling, the creator of the harry potter series, gives us a great one. I have read this book at least six times, and there is one thing that sticks with me as a plothole. Thats because hes being raised by his miserable aunt and uncle who are terrified harry will learn that hes really a wizard, just as his parents were. Especially with the whole barty crouch backround, it just says that they find that it is barty crouch jr. Sirius black, harrys godfather, suspects that this is another plot against harrys life.
Harry potter and the goblet of fire harry potter, book 4 kindle edition by rowling, j. It had a combined firstprinting of over five million copies. Okay, so the entire goblet of fire story is one big plot hole, book and film. Harry potter book will get new cover treatments in the u. Harry potter and the goblet of fire has been listed as one of the language and literature good articles under the good article criteria. If that was the plot hole the entire resurrection of voldemort was probably different and so parts of most of the book had to be rewritten to fit the new ending. Please include any sources so i can rummage around online. Even though there have been conflict and stakes prior to this, the cup is this storys main conflict, hence this is the inciting event. Harry potter and the goblet of fire book plot the book that could legitimately be called the turning point of the series is packed with action, backstory and significant darkness. Dumbledore makes moody admit that he is an imposter and that the real moody is locked in a chest. Im always a bit surprised by how many people consider this to be their favorite harry potter book.
Rowling offers up equal parts danger and delightand any number of dragons, houseelves, and deathdefying challenges. Mafalda was lost as a result because the character was not carrying out the function she wanted it to. Rowling and the fourth novel in the harry potter series. Even though there have been conflict and stakes prior to this, the cup is this storys main conflict, hence this is the inciting event first plot point. There seems to be no other proof in the books of casting having these kind of limits. Now, with harry potter and the goblet of fire, the fourth book in her seven volume epic about the titular boy wizard, j. But in 2004, rowling answered this question in an interview at. The harry potter books and films are certainly wellwritten, but here are 10 plotholes in the goblet of fire that were still thinking about. Does anyone know what plot hole jk had to fix in the. Harry is exhausted after practicing accio dozenshundreds of times for his first trial in goblet of fire but thats to be expected. Harry potter goblet of fire plot hole filled greg ladens blog. Harry potter and the goblet of fire summary shmoop.
Aug 04, 2000 now, with harry potter and the goblet of fire, the fourth book in her seven volume epic about the titular boy wizard, j. Rowling presents up equal elements hazard and delightand any quantity of dragons, homeelves, and dyingdefying challenges. Then i was teetering between goblet of fire and triwizard. Harry potter plot holes and questions explained time.
His camera should be totally nonfunctional while hes on school groundsbut somehow, colin is able to happily snap away. Also possible that the plot hole was the whole voldemort cant touch harry thing. How come girls didnt want to date harry in the fourth book. After arriving at hogwarts after voldemorts death eaters made a debacle of the world quidditch cup, harry and the others learn of the triwizard cup competition. It just occurred to me after my second readthrough of harry potter that the. It follows harry potter, a wizard in his fourth year at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, and the mystery surrounding the entry of harrys name into the triwizard tournament, in which he is forced to compete. This is the the biggest plot hole in harry potter indy100. A character that was cut from the final story was the plot hole. What was the plothole in gof that made jkr rewrite half. Goblet of fire is a fun, exciting book, one which takes us deep into the world of witches and wizards and leaves us all set up for darker things to come. However, it wouldnt make sense for an 11 or 12 year old to know what she needed to. Dec 24, 2018 at the end of the third task voldemort is ressurected and the death eaters feel their dark marks burning and join him. Harry potter goblet of fire plot hole filled greg laden. She was a weasley cousin related to ron weasley, harrys best.
The plot is actionpacked, the dialogue witty, and the characters almost all of whom are either indian or partindian are compelling, diverse, and complex. What are the biggest plot holes and errors in harry potter. Harry potter and the goblet of fire, book 4 audiobook by. Mar 17, 2017 i have read this book at least six times, and there is one thing that sticks with me as a plothole. I think we can pretty much deduce from jos interviews that she came across some major plot hole partway through the book and she fixed it. And the whole profile of the books got so much higher since the third book. Goblet of fire was the first book in the harry potter series to be released in the united states on the same date as the united kingdom, strategically on a saturday so children did not have to worry about school conflicting with buying the book. At the end of the third task voldemort is ressurected and the death eaters feel their dark marks burning and join him. Most of us never even noticed the plot holes until about the fifth read through, and even then we just didnt care. Harry potter and the goblet of fire introduction shmoop.
Perfect for acing essays, tests, and quizzes, as well as for writing lesson plans. Not only is the wizarding world strange enough to have only developed one sport, the single sport that they have makes zero sense. It follows harry potter, a magician in his fourth year at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry, and the mystery surrounding the entrance of harrys name into the triwizard tournament. Harry potter and the goblet of fire 2005 plot summary. As current, the goblet of fire plot section is shorter than any other book, which includes the first three books, which are much shorter than this one. Its a bit of an oddball, stuck in the middle between the whimsical first three books and the darker, more. According to multiple sources, the reason goblet of fire is such a long book is because jk rowling realised she had written her way into a massive plot hole and had. Rowling and the fourth publication in the harry potter collection. I think that the plot needs to be expanded a bit to get more detail in. Maybe not the most substantial in plot of the series, but it certainly has a high entertainment value to it. I recently discovered that there is a widespread belief that there is a huge, gaping, plot hole in harry potter goblet of fire by j. If it no longer meets these criteria, you can reassess it harry potter and the goblet of fire is part of the harry potter novels series, a good topic. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of harry potter and the goblet of fire and what it means.
Why did someone like harry have so much difficulty finding a date. Harry potter and the goblet of fire is the fourth book in the series of harry potter fantasy novels by british author j. K download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. She didnt outright explain it, though she did often mention how much goblet of fire gave her trouble, because she had an extremely tight deadline and delivered a very long book. Download harry potter and the goblet of fire pdf ebook. The ultimate result of most of the books plot is to get harry potter transported to the clutches of the dark lord in order to contribute, as an. I have spoken before now about the weasley cousin who made it quite a long way into goblet of fire before. Get here plot hole harry potter and the goblet of fire harry potter has no idea how famous he is. Harry potter and the goblet of fire summary supersummary. Does anybody know what the plot hole was in goblet of fire. Rowling finds herself guardian of an international pop phenom and a. As moody is about to kill harry, dumbledore, snape, and mcgonagall burst in the room and save harry.
Harry potter and the goblet of fire novel mugglenet. Mistakes in the harry potter books harry potter wiki fandom. Harry potter and the goblet of fire plot hole showing 14 of 4. Aug 26, 2010 she didnt outright explain it, though she did often mention how much goblet of fire gave her trouble, because she had an extremely tight deadline and delivered a very long book. How did jk rowling address the plothole in goblet of fire.
The magic goblet of fire chooses one champion to represent each school, but somehow harry is also chosen, even though he is underage and hogwarts already has a champion. Rowling, and continues the adventures of the young wizard and his classmates, now in their fourth year at hogwarts school of witchcraft and wizardry. However, a later revelation in goblet of firethe fact that muggle technology doesnt work at hogwartssuggests that colins hobby of photography is actually a major plot hole in the series. In short, i think she realized the plothole was there, later in the game, but pressures from the publisher to get a book a year out the door kept her from addressing. Harry potter and the goblet of fire pdf book download. Harry is forced into competing after the goblet of fire is hoodwinked and must face off against dragons, merfolk, death eaters, magical creatures galore, and eventually the dark lord himself. Were taking a look at ten strange plot holes from the series that were never resolved. It has 37 chapters and is 635 pages long in the uk and 734 pages long in the us. School resumes, and harry is frustrated that few people believe he didnt place his own name in the goblet of fire. And please include anything else you want to, hprelated or not.
1033 711 874 1527 916 1444 1080 600 664 1289 1018 576 722 97 785 264 853 276 1602 42 1517 384 812 1471 1361 917 279 55 1222 354 1074 774 1419 1109 518 1449